← Footnotes & Sources

Source Report Card

Chapter 15: Two Thousand Years of "Soon"

Source Who When Chain Rung Grade
2 Peter 3:3-9; Jude 1:18; D&C 45:26; 2 Nephi 28:21 Peter; Jude; the Lord through Joseph Smith; Nephi Various 1st 1 A+
D&C 45:28-31 ("that generation" tied to a "light"; no year) The Lord through Joseph Smith ca. 7 Mar 1831 1st 1 A+
Matthew 24:34, 36, 48; JS–Matthew 1:34, 48; D&C 49:7; Revelation 22:7, 20 Jesus Christ; the Lord through Joseph Smith; John Various 1st 1 A+
D&C 84:3-5 (temple "in this generation"); D&C 124:49-51 (work required "no more") The Lord through Joseph Smith Sept 1832; Jan 1841 1st 1 A+ (solid source; a hard passage)
D&C 130:14-17 Joseph Smith (canonized from clerks' notes) 2 Apr 1843 1st (canonized) 1 A+
Old Testament Student Manual, ch. 28 (Daniel 12) Church Educational System 2003 1st 2 A
Proclamation of the Twelve ("not many years hence") Quorum of the Twelve 1845 1st 2 A (real, didn't happen)
Christofferson, "The Character of Christ," General Conference D. Todd Christofferson (Second Counselor in the First Presidency) Apr 2026 1st 3 A
Letter to Noah C. Saxton ("now living"; no Second Coming date) Joseph Smith 4 Jan 1833 1st 4 B (real, only partly happened)
Letter to the editor, Times and Seasons ("not in 1843") Joseph Smith 28 Feb 1843 1st 4 B
Letter to Lyman Wight et al. (conditional "If" date for redeeming Zion) Joseph Smith 16 Aug 1834 1st 4 B (real, conditional)
Discourse ("rising generation"; "if" framing; 40 years, murkier in Clayton) Joseph Smith (Willard Richards, then an apostle; William Clayton) 6 Apr 1843 2nd, multiple notes 4 B
Discourse ("will not come in 1844"; "about 1890"; Clayton's "I neve[r] said") Joseph Smith (single note each: Richards, then an apostle, for 1844 and 1890; Clayton for "I neve[r] said") 6 Apr 1843 2nd, single note 4 C
Discourse ("no man knoweth" applied to people then) Joseph Smith (James Burgess) 6 Apr 1843 2nd, single notebook (copied after 12 Apr 1843) 4 C
Discourse ("not this year"; "not in forty years") Joseph Smith (Woodruff and W. Richards, then apostles; Bullock) 10 Mar 1844 2nd, multiple notes 4 B
Discourse ("never did reveal to any man the precise time") Joseph Smith (Wilford Woodruff, then an apostle, only) 10 Mar 1844 2nd, single note 4 C
Minutes ("even fifty six years") Joseph Smith (clerk's summary, copied into Minute Book 1 in 1836) 14 Feb 1835 2nd, single record 4 C (didn't happen)
James Burgess notebook ("1805 / 85 / 1890", written under his notes of the 10 Mar 1844 discourse) James Burgess (a member) 10 Mar 1844 1st (his own arithmetic) 5 C
Parley P. Pratt, Mormonism Unveiled, pp. 14-15 ("50 years hence") Parley P. Pratt (then Quorum of the Twelve) 1838 1st 4 B (real, didn't happen)
Journal of Discourses 2:259-266 (D&C 45:30 read as the 1830 generation) Orson Pratt (then Quorum of the Twelve), clerk's shorthand report 7 Apr 1855 2nd 4 C (real, didn't happen)
McConkie, Doctrinal New Testament Commentary 3:590, on Rev. 22:7 (quoted in NT Student Manual) Bruce R. McConkie (then Quorum of the Twelve; a Seventy until Oct 1972) 1973 1st 4 B